Once Upon a Time in America (1984) Cast & Character Guide — No Spoilers | Who's That?

Who plays who in Once Upon a Time in America (1984)? Browse a spoiler-free character guide with photos of every major character and the actors behind them, including Robert De Niro, James Woods, Elizabeth McGovern.

• Noodles — played by Robert De Niro
• Max — played by James Woods
• Deborah — played by Elizabeth McGovern
• Frankie — played by Joe Pesci
• Joe — played by Burt Young
• Carol — played by Tuesday Weld
• Jimmy O'Donnell — played by Treat Williams
• Police Chief Aiello — played by Danny Aiello
• Chicken Joe — played by Richard Bright
• Patsy — played by James Hayden
• Cockeye — played by William Forsythe
• Eve — played by Darlanne Fluegel
• Fat Moe — played by Larry Rapp
• Whitey — played by Richard Foronjy
• Sharkey — played by Robert Harper
• Van Linden — played by Dutch Miller
• Crowning — played by Gerard Murphy
• Peggy — played by Amy Ryder
• Woman in Puppet Theatre — played by Olga Karlatos
• Mandy — played by Mario Brega